Pick Board Games

Dungeon crawlers5 games

The best board games like HeroQuest

HeroQuest made plastic doors, miniature gargoyles, and Saturday-afternoon dungeon crawls unforgettable, but its 1989 roll-and-move rules and mandatory Zargon player show their age. These five modern games keep the miniatures, loot, and dungeon exploration while letting everyone at the table play on the same side.

This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we earn a commission and you pay the same.

Players
1–6
Age
7+
At the table
30–180 min

One by one

The 5 best board games like HeroQuest, compared

Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion
  • Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion: the board set up
  • Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion: a game in progress
  • Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion: the components

Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion

Cephalofair Games · 2020

  • 1–4players
  • 14+years
  • 30–120 minat the table

Trades HeroQuest's dice rolling and human Dungeon Master for two-card tactical turns where enemy decks run the monsters automatically. Instead of digging through cardboard map tiles, you open a spiral-bound scenario book and put your miniatures right on the page. The first five missions add rules one step at a time before opening up into a 25-scenario city campaign.

What works

  • Plays straight out of the spiral-bound scenario book, cutting setup and teardown down to minutes
  • Five-scenario tutorial teaches the card-driven combat gradually without a massive rulebook dump
  • Four distinct heroes—Red Guard, Hatchet, Voidwarden, and Demolitionist—with zero throwaway turns

What to watch for

  • No dice chucking; every move and attack is a tight hand-management puzzle with high mental overhead
  • Burning your best cards too early can leave your hero exhausted right before the end of a 90-minute mission
See priceamazon.com
Descent: Legends of the Dark
  • Descent: Legends of the Dark: the board set up
  • Descent: Legends of the Dark: the components
  • Descent: Legends of the Dark: the components

Descent: Legends of the Dark

Fantasy Flight Games · 2021

  • 1–4players
  • 14+years
  • 120–180 minat the table

If your favorite part of HeroQuest was the 3D furniture on the board, this is its modern evolution. Forty miniatures climb stairs, search bookshelves, and fight across multi-level 3D terrain while a companion app runs the monsters, tracks damage, and handles town crafting between the 16 campaign quests. Instead of rolling to see if you whiff, your hero flips double-sided weapon and skill cards to clear fatigue and switch combat styles mid-fight.

What works

  • 46 pieces of interactive 3D terrain and multi-level maps give the board massive tabletop presence
  • The companion app runs monster behavior, story events, and town crafting so nobody has to play Zargon
  • Flipping double-sided weapon and skill cards clears fatigue and changes your hero's attacks on the fly

What to watch for

  • Requires a tablet or computer at the table for every single action and attack
  • Sessions easily run two to three hours, and the 3D cardboard terrain takes hours to assemble before your first game
See priceamazon.com
Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape
  • Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape: the board set up
  • Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape: the components
  • Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape: the components

Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape

CMON Global Limited · 2022

  • 1–6players
  • 14+years
  • 60 minat the table

Keeps the pure dice-chucking, door-kicking spirit of HeroQuest, ditches the human Dungeon Master, and cranks up the loot and hero variety for up to six players. Each of the six classes uses a completely different system—the Rogue draws tokens from a bag, the Wizard spins a spell wheel, and the Shaman summons elemental spirits. You level up fast and pull common, rare, and epic gear out of a treasure bag inside a single one-shot mission.

What works

  • Six wildly asymmetric hero classes that each play like their own mini-game
  • Fast single-session progression with shared XP, custom combat dice, and a bag full of upgrading loot
  • Supports up to six players cooperatively and comes packed with 68 detailed miniatures

What to watch for

  • Story is bare-bones across the 10 core scenarios unless you buy the separate campaign expansion
  • No box insert for the cards and tokens, making setup and teardown a 20-minute sorting chore
See priceamazon.com
Chronicles of Avel
  • Chronicles of Avel: the board set up
  • Chronicles of Avel: the components
  • Chronicles of Avel: the components

Chronicles of Avel

Rebel Sp. z o.o. · 2021

  • 1–4players
  • 8+years
  • 60 minat the table

Built for families who want a cooperative fantasy quest they can finish in an hour with kids aged eight and up. Players color and name their own hero sheets, uncover hexagonal map tiles, and roll dice to defeat monsters before the Beast marches on the castle. Whenever you win a fight, you reach into a cloth bag and feel around by touch to pull out cardboard weapons, shields, and potions that fit into your hero's puzzle-grid backpack.

What works

  • Tactile loot bag where players search by touch for weapons and potions to fit into their backpack grid
  • Tower-defense finale where the traps and castle walls you built all game hold back the Beast
  • Forgiving knockout rules—stunned heroes return to the castle and heal instead of sitting out the game

What to watch for

  • Uses cardboard monster tokens instead of the plastic miniatures and 3D furniture HeroQuest fans love
  • Combat and loot pulls rely heavily on dice luck and blind draws

No buying link

Mice and Mystics
  • Mice and Mystics: the board set up
  • Mice and Mystics: a game in progress
  • Mice and Mystics: the components

Mice and Mystics

Plaid Hat Games · 2012

  • 1–4players
  • 7+years
  • 60–90 minat the table

Turns the classic dungeon crawl into an 11-chapter fairy tale where heroes transformed into mice scurry through castle kitchens, drainpipes, and floorboards. Everyone plays together against an automated initiative track of rats, cockroaches, spiders, and Brodie the housecat, collecting cheese crumbs to power special abilities. Double-sided tiles let your party flip the board from the room above to the tunnels underneath.

What works

  • Rich 11-chapter storybook campaign that pulls kids as young as seven straight into the adventure
  • Clever double-sided room tiles that flip between castle floors and mouse tunnels underneath
  • Simple dice combat and cheese-crumb abilities that are easy for beginners to learn

What to watch for

  • Combat and movement rely heavily on dice rolls, which can make chapters feel swingy when luck turns cold
  • Less tactical depth for veteran gamers once the storybook charm wears off
See priceamazon.com

At a glance

All five dungeon crawlers side by side

Marks the most useful extreme in each row: largest group, youngest age, shortest game.

5 games compared
FeatureGloomhaven: Jaws of the LionDescent: Legends of the DarkMassive Darkness 2: HellscapeChronicles of AvelMice and Mystics
Players1–41–41–6the largest group1–41–4
Age14+14+14+8+7+the lowest age
At the table30–120 minthe shortest game120–180 min60 min60 min60–90 min
PublisherCephalofair GamesFantasy Flight GamesCMON Global LimitedRebel Sp. z o.o.Plaid Hat Games
Year20202021202220212012
BuySee priceSee priceSee price

No buying link

See price

Which one fits your table

  • For tactical combat and fast setup

    Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion

    Replaces dice and cardboard map tiles with a 25-mission spiral-bound scenario book and deep two-card turns.

  • For 3D terrain and zero bookkeeping

    Descent: Legends of the Dark

    Multi-level 3D scenery and 40 miniatures paired with a smart companion app that runs the monsters and town crafting.

  • For pure dice-chucking and loot up to 6 players

    Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape

    Closest to HeroQuest's hack-and-slash spirit, with 68 miniatures, six asymmetric hero classes, and single-session leveling.

  • For a one-hour family quest with kids

    Chronicles of Avel

    Ages 8 and up, modular hex exploration, a touch-based loot bag, and a castle defense finale in 60 minutes.

  • For a storybook campaign with younger children

    Mice and Mystics

    Ages 7 and up, turning players into heroic mice across an 11-chapter fairy tale with simple dice combat.

More adventure, mystery, and game night guides

Best Halloween Board Games: 6 Spooky Picks for Game Night6 games · 1–99 players · from 8 years · up to 60 min5 Best Board Games Like Clue for Adults (Modern Mystery)5 games · 1–12 players · from 10 years · up to 90 minQuick Family Board Games: 4 Picks You Can Finish in 30 Minutes4 games · 2–10 players · from 7 years · up to 45 min

Questions

Frequently asked questions about games like HeroQuest

Does HeroQuest still hold up today by modern board game standards?

HeroQuest still works as a simple, nostalgia-packed gateway game for kids and casual groups, and its plastic miniatures and 3D furniture look great on the table. By modern design standards, though, its roll-and-move movement, repetitive early quests, samey melee heroes, and thankless human Zargon role feel dated compared to games like Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion or Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape.

What are the best modern alternatives to HeroQuest that don't require a Dungeon Master?

All five games in this guide are 100% cooperative and need no human Dungeon Master. Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion and Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape run enemy turns with automated behavior decks, Descent: Legends of the Dark uses a companion app to control monsters and story events, and Chronicles of Avel and Mice and Mystics let the whole table play together using simple dice and card tracks.

Can you play these HeroQuest alternatives solo or without a second player?

Yes, all five games in this guide include dedicated solo play right out of the box. Unlike classic HeroQuest—which requires at least one hero and a human Zargon—these modern alternatives automate monster behavior and dungeon events. Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion and Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape run enemies using tactical monster cards, Descent: Legends of the Dark offloads monster AI and story events to a free companion app, and both Chronicles of Avel and Mice and Mystics allow a single player to control multiple adventurers through cooperative dice-and-tile exploration.

Is the official HeroQuest companion app good or too intrusive?

The HeroQuest companion app lets everyone play cooperatively without a human Zargon, but it requires tedious manual input—you have to trace every single square your heroes walk on the screen and then move the physical pieces to match. If you want an app-driven dungeon crawler built from the ground up for digital play, Descent: Legends of the Dark is far smoother, handling line of sight, enemy AI, status effects, and between-mission crafting without making the physical board feel redundant.

Why is roll-and-move considered outdated in modern dungeon crawlers?

Rolling two six-sided dice just to walk down a hallway means a bad roll (like snake eyes) can waste your entire turn before you even reach a door. Modern dungeon crawlers replace random movement with fixed action points or movement cards—like the three-action turns in Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape and Descent: Legends of the Dark, or the dual-purpose action cards in Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion—so your positioning is a tactical choice rather than luck.

Is HeroQuest worth its price tag compared to modern alternatives?

Unless you are buying it specifically for 1990s nostalgia or its classic miniatures, your money goes further elsewhere. Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion costs a fraction of HeroQuest's price while delivering a 25-scenario tactical campaign right out of its spiral-bound map book, and Massive Darkness 2: Hellscape packs 68 miniatures and six asymmetric hero classes into a much richer cooperative system.

What are the best kid-friendly or beginner dungeon crawlers like HeroQuest?

For families with kids, Chronicles of Avel (ages 8+) and Mice and Mystics (ages 7+) are the best places to start. Chronicles of Avel plays in 60 minutes, lets kids draw gear from a cloth bag by touch, and never eliminates knocked-out players. Mice and Mystics wraps simple dice combat in an 11-chapter storybook adventure where heroes play as field mice battling rats, spiders, and the castle cat.

Updated 19 October 2026 · from our own catalogue